Freestanding or Built-in Bathtub: Which One Should You Choose?


People are giving their homes extra attention these days. In fact, reports show spending in the home improvement industry reached more than $95 billion last year. Homeowners concentrate on many areas of their homes, including the kitchen, attic, basement, and outdoor spaces. At this point, though, the bathroom is the primary focal point for most.

Related: 11 Steps to Remodeling Your Bathroom

Why Are Bathroom Remodels So Popular?

Homeowners cite several reasons for revamping their bathrooms. Some do so because the bathrooms in their homes don’t meet their needs and preferences. Others remodel their bathrooms because their existing ones are in disrepair.

Quite a few say they just can’t stand to look at their old bathrooms any longer. Many are simply celebrating the fact that they finally have the resources to carry out such a project after years of hoping and planning. Regardless of their reasons, one of the main considerations for a bathroom remodel is which type of bathtub to have installed.

Related: 8 Top Bathroom Remodeling Trends of 2020-2021


Bathtubs: Exploring Your Options

Until fairly recently, homeowners had few choices when it came to bathtubs because the traditional clawfoot design was the only option available. Popularized during the late 1800s, this type of bath literally began as nothing more than an enamel-covered horse trough with decorative feet attached to the bottom. Of course, it quickly became the epitome of style and luxury.

In the 1920s, built-in tubs entered the mix. They’re the ones we know so well today. Built-in tubs are surrounded by walls on three sides whereas freestanding models are detached. These days, you’ll find an extensive selection of bathtubs made of various materials. Both types of baths have their benefits and disadvantages.


Comparing Built-in Baths and Freestanding Tubs

Numerous people enjoy soaking in a hot, luxurious bath after a long day. Doing so offers plenty of health benefits as well. Of course, a bathtub can make or break the entire experience. If you’re struggling to decide which type of tub would best suit your needs and expectations, several factors come into play. We’ll take a look at some of the most important points.

67 Inch Hammered Copper Double Slipper Bathtub With Rings

67 Inch Hammered Copper Double Slipper Bathtub With Rings

Flexibility

When it comes to flexibility and freedom of choice, many people insist freestanding tubs are the clear winners. They can essentially be installed anywhere in the bathroom as long as it’s possible to tap into the plumbing from the desired location. You could have a freestanding tub installed near a window, in a secluded corner, or even in the middle of the room under some circumstances. At the same time, you can design the remainder of the bathroom around the location of the tub.

Built-in baths don’t offer quite the same level of freedom. They must be installed against a wall and have either walls or dividers on two additional sides. This can save a certain amount of space in bathrooms where square footage is limited, but it leaves little flexibility. That said, the design of the space surrounding a built-in tub can certainly add a great deal of style and beauty to a bathroom.

Related: 7 Ways To Brighten Your Dark Bathroom


Aesthetic Appeal

Freestanding tubs have long been associated with beauty. Something about their decorative feet and refined designs just exudes elegance. Those feet can be traditional and ornate or plain and simple, and even the latter doesn’t detract from the style and appearance of the bath or its surrounding fixtures and décor.

Though many standalone tubs follow the conventional clawfoot design, a number of more conventional alternatives are available as well. Some stand on solid pedestals rather than feet. Others take on a bowl-like appearance. Those newer designs often meld well with more contemporary bathrooms.

In the past, built-in baths were considered dull and dated. Of course, that has changed significantly in recent years. An endless array of lovely built-in tub designs is available. Again, the surrounding elements make all the difference. With marble, tile, decorative backsplashes, and other features, built-in tubs can be as contemporary and elegant as their standalone counterparts.


Selection

Both freestanding and built-in baths have branched out significantly over the years. Each one boasts several styles and designs. Still, freestanding models are a bit more limited than their enclosed cousins.

Freestanding baths are typically made of either cast iron or acrylic, but they can be fabricated of fiberglass and other materials. Most are the traditional elongated shape most of us recognize and measure around five or six feet in length though various other shapes and sizes are on the market.

Built-in tubs are generally composed of acrylic or fiberglass these days as opposed to the porcelain models of the past. You’ll find a long list of shapes and sizes at your disposal, including large, spa-style versions complete with raised seating, massaging jets, and other features.

68 Inch White Acrylic Freestanding Tub

68 Inch White Acrylic Freestanding Tub

Comfort

Many people choose freestanding tubs over built-in models because of their sheer comfort and luxury. They tend to offer plenty of room to stretch out and relax and can often accommodate two people comfortably. On the other hand, freestanding baths are notorious for losing heat quickly because of their composition and being vulnerable to the open air. Acrylic models don’t go cold as easily as metal ones, but they still create a sense of urgency to finish the bath and get out.

Although standard built-in tubs don’t offer the same level of spacious comfort as freestanding models, many new designs excel in this department. They’re made with luxury and legroom in mind. On top of that, being closed in and having the benefit of insulation from surrounding walls ensures the water will stay warm for a bit longer than it does in most freestanding tubs.


Cost

Most people have a set budget for their bathroom remodels, so managing the costs involved is certainly a factor. On their own, built-in bathtubs are typically less expensive than freestanding models. Of course, you could easily make up the difference in cost with the materials and surrounding elements you choose for your bathroom renovation. Freestanding tubs don’t require all those extra additions, so their higher base costs may balance out in the end.

From the perspective of installation costs, both types of bathtubs are comparable. With a freestanding bath, some plumbing considerations could drive up the cost. If you choose a location for the tub that isn’t already equipped with fittings for faucets, the cost will naturally be higher. On the other hand, expenses often mount when you’re having dividers, tiles, and other features installed for a built-in tub as well.

Related: How to Create a Bathroom Remodel Budget

So Which Bathtub Is Best?

In most cases, people choose freestanding tubs purely because of their style and decorative appeal. They give you greater freedom of choice in terms of placement. One of the biggest drawbacks of freestanding baths is how quickly they allow the water to grow cold. New models made of contemporary materials are more effective at holding in heat than older, more traditional versions, but they often don’t measure up to built-in baths.

Built-in bathtubs are typically less expensive and more efficient. They’re not quite as decorative as many freestanding tubs, but you can enhance their appearance in numerous ways. While freestanding baths offer more flexibility where placement is concerned, built-in models bring you more versatility and a broader selection of styles and designs.

If you’re looking for traditional elegance and a have distinct preference of where your bathtub will be installed, a freestanding bath may be the best way to go. Otherwise, a built-in tub might be a more suitable solution. In the end, it all boils down to your preferences, space, and budget. No matter which one you choose, the possibilities are virtually endless.

Related: How to Remodel a Bathroom on a Budget

67 Inch White Acrylic Tub

67 Inch White Acrylic Tub

Resources:

https://www.fixr.com/comparisons/freestanding-vs-built-in-tub#cQ

https://blog.taylormorrison.com/2019/05/bathtub/

https://www.remodelista.com/posts/built-in-vs-freestanding-bathtubs-pros-and-cons-remodeling-101/

Comments are closed.